The Apocryphal Culpeppers
Home Up Index Search Sending Info DNA About
 

The Apocryphal Culpeppers

In the early 1900's, perhaps even earlier, a fascinating version of early American Culpepper genealogy circulated among Culpepper family members.

bulletIt contained an account of a brave patriot overthrowing a tyrant, becoming the Governor of Virginia, and being called the father of Charleston.
bulletThere was a farm boy who went to England to be educated at Oxford, and in a story befitting a book of fairy tales, he finds and marries his childhood sweetheart.
bulletOne Culpepper marries a beautiful Indian half-breed, faithfully works as overseer on a plantation that once belonged to his ancestors, and his sons eventually receive a huge land grant as recompense for the family plantation having been stolen.
bulletAnother becomes a highly successful orator/preacher winning many souls to Christ.
bulletA Culpepper daughter marries into the family of a famous American patriot. In fact, virtually all of the Culpepper daughters in this story marry quite well.
bulletOne reprobate son was included for good measure. A whiskey maker, he changes his surname to Pepper to shield his pious mother from disgrace.
bulletAlso, each of the major characters was described in extraordinarily precise physical detail.

Human nature makes any reader want to embrace this detailed and rich genealogical account as the true story of his or her ancestors. And for several generations, this genealogy has been accepted by many as the gospel, and passed along to the next.

However, modern day researchers attempting to verify the facts encounter many difficulties. Most of the assertions are without proof, but many of them should be provable if they were true. And some of the claims are clearly at odds with the historical record.

All Culpeppers and Culpepper descendants can certainly be inspired by the understanding that we are members of a quite honorable and accomplished family. Within the provable genealogical record we can find much to be proud of in our Culpepper ancestral history, and we can do so without resorting to imaginative creation.

In the table that follows, the most detailed version of this apocryphal genealogy is shown in the left column, and Culpepper Connections' commentary is in the right. We have included here the first four generations of American Culpeppers depicted within the apocryphal work. They are John Marlo Culpepper, Thomas Fairfax Culpepper, Sam Low Culpepper and Charles Marion Culpepper.

The Culpepper Connections commentary was primarily authored by Lewis W. Griffin, Jr. of Phoenix, AZ, and edited by Warren L. Culpepper of Big Canoe, GA. It is our considered opinion that the genealogical account reported below is completely fictitious. If you have any facts to add to our analysis, or if you wish to dispute our conclusion, we would welcome hearing from you.

One Version of the "Apocryphal Culpepper" Genealogy

Culpepper Connections’ Commentary

John Marlo Culpepper

Height 6 feet‚ 2 inches; weight 184 lbs.; color of eyes blue. Special marks of identification: right eye slightly smaller‚ large mole on body.

John Marlo Culpeper was born in England 10 May 1633.

No evidence has ever been found for John Culpepper’s middle name of Marlo, and middle names, in general, were not common until about 100 years later. According to Fairfax Harrison, The Proprietors of the Northern Neck "He was baptised in Hollingbourne‚ April 4‚ 1633‚ as ’John‚ sonne of Thomas Culpeper‚ esq.’" Estate records (Albemarle Co.‚ NC 4 Apr 1797) list the name as "Jno. Culpepper."

Was appointed General Surveyor of the Carolinas under Charles II.

John Culpeper was appointed Surveyor General by the Lords Proprietors in 1671.

It was he who laid out the city of Charles Town‚ afterward called Charleston. His work as Surveyor took him to all parts of Carolina.

Although he was noted in Virginia and North Carolina land records and in New England shipping records‚ the only surveying activity noted was in Charleston‚ SC.

His democratic spirit won for him the love and confidence of the people‚ which made him the Master Spirit in the insurrection that took away the power of the self-appointed officiary of the Carolina Colonies and placed in authority officers elected by the people.

This is obviously a reference to the John Culpeper associated with Culpeper’s Rebellion in 1677.

Because of this‚ he was relieved of his official position as General Surveyor and the establisher of bounds to the different grants issued by the crown.

According to Fairfax Harrison‚ John Culpeper fled from South Carolina. Some sources suggest a food shortage and others suggest that‚ his sister‚ Frances‚ and brother-in-law‚ Sir William Berkeley‚ the Governor of Virginia‚ were involved in a land deal in Albemarle‚ NC which necessitated John Culpeper’s rapid removal. As noted above‚ Bacon’s Rebellion against Gov. Berkeley took place in 1676 and one wonders if this was in some way connected with John Culpeper’s hasty move north. In any event‚ by July 1677‚ John Culpeper was residing in Albemarle‚ NC‚ probably on land owned by his brother-in-law‚ Sir William Berkeley. In December 1677‚ John allegedly usurped the government from a Collector of the King’s Customs named Miller who was a temporary Deputy Governor. In fact‚ although associated with one of the factions in the rebellion‚ John Culpepper was away from the colony in the months preceding the revolt and arrived back only shortly before it took place. He was directed by the group to be the Custom’s Collector in the place of Miller‚ and for this‚ he went on trial in England. 

Was arrested‚ taken back to England‚

He went voluntarily. He was not arrested until he tried to return to Albemarle. For more factual detail on Culpeper's Rebellion and John's role within it, see William Smith's Master's thesis: Culpeper's Rebellion: New Data and Old Problems.

there tried for treason‚

Colepeper’s Case

but was cleared of the charge. Where upon the King reinstated him‚ and returned him to his work.

No account of his subsequent career has been found. 

It was on 8 Apr 1655 that he married Ruth Jane Peck--born 23 Oct 1638‚ died 3 May 1684.

There is no record of this marriage. According to p. 24 of A Journal of the Grand Council of S. C.‚ John Culpeper’s wife’s name was Judith. John Culpeper later married Sarah Mayo.

To this union four children were born‚ viz.‚

  1. Annie‚ who married S. P. Sumner and by whom six children were born‚ there being four boys and two girls;
  2. Mattie‚ who never married;
  3. Thomas F.--see line below--;
  4. Charles B.‚ who never married‚ is thought to have perished at sea.

The unnamed "orphans of Jno. Culpeper" were noted in surviving estate records (The Colonial Records of North Carolina, Second Series, Vol. III: North Carolina Higher Court Records, 1697-1701, Raleigh, NC: North Carolina Division of Archives and History, Historical Publications Section, 1971, p. 5) but only one daughter‚ Sarah Culpeper‚ has ever been identified because she was listed as a step-daughter in the estate papers of Sarah (Mayo) Culpeper’s husband‚ Patrick Henley. There is no record of a marriage between an Annie Culpeper and S. P. Sumner.

John Marlo Culpeper was a first cousin to Lord Culpeper who was Gov. of VA for awhile‚ whose rule was anything but pleasing both to the Virginia Colony and to his King.

John Culpeper was a second cousin to Thomas, 2nd Lord Culpeper.

All, however, loved John Marlo‚ and in old age he was called father by the people of Charleston. He lived 60 years to the very day and almost the hour‚ dying 10 May 1693‚ in the home of his daughter‚ Mrs. Sumner.

Fairfax Harrison noted "no final record of this John Culpeper has come to light" but‚ as noted above‚ John’s wife‚ Sarah‚ married Patrick Henley and they are noted in 24 Feb 1695 executing "the last will & testament of John Culpeper late of Pascotank [NC]‚ Gent. dec’d" North Carolina History and Genealogical Register, p. 259. There is no evidence that Mrs. Sumner was John’s daughter or that John died in her home.

Thomas Fairfax Culpeper

Height 5 feet 8 inches; weight 170 lbs; color of eyes gray. Special marks of identification: a large mole on body‚ a deep scar on chin.

Thomas Fairfax Culpeper was born in Northern Carolina‚ 20 Nov 1660.

At this date‚ the colony did not exist. The alleged father of Thomas‚ John Culpeper‚ the "Carolina Rebel‚" became associated with this area circa 1677‚ probably because his sister‚ Frances‚ and brother-in-law‚ Gov. Berkeley of Virginia‚ had an interest in the property. Or possibly he came there as a result of Bacon’s Rebellion against Gov. Berkeley in 1676.

Was sent to Oxford‚ England‚ to college‚ where he graduated with the degree of Bachelor of Arts in May 1681.

A comprehensive list of Oxford graduates during 1500-1866 shows no Thomas Culpeper or Colepeper receiving a degree at this time. Sir Thomas Colepeper, baronet, son of Richard Colepeper of Preston Hall, Kent, did matriculate 15 Jun 1672 at age 15, but is not reported to have received a degree.

It was on 1 Jun 1681‚ just a few days after graduation‚ that he married Sarah Ray--born 18 Nov 1662‚ died 2 Dec 1724--with whom he had been in love since he was a boy of 12 years‚ at which time he had visited his maternal grandparents living near Portsmouth‚ England. It was while playing along the coast they had met and together had gathered shells. One day Sarah found a tiny mussel shell and dividing it‚ she gave to Thomas a half and kept the other half herself. Thomas returned to the colony but no one there was able either to get the shell or learn its secret. When in his last year at college they had again met‚ each demanded to see the other half. One half was found to be on a gold chain worn about the neck of Sarah‚ the other half in the pocket of Thomas. The care taken of the bits of shell told to each other more of the story of love‚ than was possible in any other way. It was not a hard task to get the consent of parents‚ so the alliance dreamed of in childhood became a reality later on. If providence ever had a hand in the affairs of love‚ surely in this case. Their life was one sweet communion‚ and when they came to the end of life here‚ neither felt like taking the longest of pilgrimages without the other. So they departed this life together and are united now in the beyond‚ if the wish of either heart was fulfilled.

No record of this marriage has been found.

Thomas after marriage returned to America‚ taught school‚ practiced law‚ and later became private secretary to Lord Culpeper‚ Gov. of VA‚ and his father’s first cousin and for whom he was named.

According to Fairfax Harrison, "Capt. Alexander Culpeper" was secretary to Thomas, second Lord Culpeper. Alexander was the brother of John Culpeper, the "Carolina Rebel" and of Frances, the wife of Sir William Berkeley, Governor of Virginia. Although Alexander was named Surveyor General of Virginia in 1671, he apparently remained in England and, in 1691, he willed the sixth part of the Northern Neck of Virginia which he had inherited, to the widow of Thomas, second Lord Culpeper.

In 1683‚ the Governor was removed from his position by the King for leaving the colony without permission. The alleged Thomas Fairfax Culpepper was supposed to have graduated from Oxford only two years earlier.

John Culpeper‚ the "Carolina Rebel"‚ and alleged father of Thomas Fairfax Culpepper‚ was a second cousin of Thomas‚ second Lord Culpeper.

Was the father of two children--twin boys‚

  1. Sam Low--see line below—and
  2. John Marlo‚ who changed his name to John Marlo Pepper‚ possibly due to the fact that he became engaged in the manufactory of whiskey and desired to shield his mother‚ a very pious woman‚ from the disgrace.

No records have ever been found with the names of Sam Low Culpeper, John Marlo Culpeper, or John Marlo Pepper

Thomas died in Charleston‚ SC‚ 2 Dec 1724.

No will or probate record has been found in South Carolina‚ nor has any record been found showing that he ever lived there. No other record of Thomas Fairfax Culpeper has ever been found‚ either in America‚ or in England.

Sam Low Culpepper

Height 6 feet; weight 160 lbs; color of eye dark blue. Special marks of identification: right eye slightly smaller‚ left-handed‚ hair very red.

Sam Low was born in Virginia‚ 3 Jul 1692. Changed the spelling of his name from two p’s to three.

John Culpepper‚ an alleged grandson‚ signed his name "John Culpeper" on an estate record in 1807 but he signed "John Culpepper" on a letter in 1853. The name was spelled several different ways in English and American records because spelling standards had not yet been established and people spelled words‚ including names‚ the way they sounded.

Became overseer and manager of that part of the Lord Thomas Fairfax estate that came to him by his wife Catherine Culpeper‚ the only daughter of Lord Thomas Culpeper.

Lord Fairfax? see notes below about husband and son of Catherine. There is no evidence that a Sam Low Culpepper ever managed this property.

Sam Low was married 19 Apr 1736‚ to Ruth Waters‚ a half-breed Indian girl of great beauty. She was born 29 Aug 1719‚ and died 1 Jan 1779.

There is no record of this marriage.

To this union eleven children were born‚ two only living to be grown;

  1. Charles Marion—see line below.
  2. Alfred Norman—born 4 Jan 1742. Became a lawyer and later moved into Maine--there married and raised a family of five boys and three girls‚ all living to be grown and married. When Alfred was last seen in VA‚ he told his brother Charles that he had thirty-eight grandchildren and that twenty were boys that would bear the family name. When he and his brother came into the VA estate‚ he--Alfred--was too old to come back and look after his share‚ so sold his part to W. P. Jones‚ the son-in-law of his brother Charles. Since then‚ all trace of him and his has been lost.

Although shipping records link the Culpeper name to the New England area‚ no record of the family has been found in Maine or New Hampshire. Prior to 1820, Maine was part of New Hampshire.

Also, no record of the sale of a share of the VA estate to W. P. Jones has ever been found.

Sam Low managed this estate for nearly forty years and died Oct 21 1763‚ without knowing that his boys would come into possession of it in their old age.

No record of Sam Low Culpepper has ever been found in any record‚ in Virginia‚ or elsewhere.

Charles Marion Culpepper

Height 5 feet 7 inches; weight 120 lbs; color of eyes blue; complexion dark; hair very black. Special marks of identification: was left-handed; large mole on body; a double thumb on right hand.

Charles Marion Culpepper was born in Culpeper County‚ VA‚ 8 Dec 1739.

Culpeper Co., VA was created in 1749 from Orange Co., VA‚ and no Culpeper/Culpepper appears in marriage‚ land‚ or probate records from either county.

Lived with his parents until their death. Was converted‚ called to preach‚ and became a Methodist Circuit rider in Virginia and Maryland. Though of limited educational attainments‚ was a speaker and preacher of unusual ability‚ being an orator of the old school.

Methodist records do not mention his ordination

It was on 3 Jun 1773 that he married Laura Lee‚ the aunt of Harry Lee known in history as "Light-horse-Harry‚" she was a sweet singer and therefore of great help to her preacher husband.

Charles Marion Culpepper is not mentioned in Lee family genealogies and no record of this marriage has been found.

To this union four children were born:

  1. John William

This is supposed to be John Culpepper, husband of Nancy Gillespie‚ and the subject of considerable research by Lew Griffin. A grandson‚ Joseph Richard Culpepper‚ after reading this history wrote to his father‚ Rev. Lewis Peek Culpepper‚ a son of John Culpepper‚ and then to his cousin‚ Rev. George Bright Culpepper‚ who also had a copy of the history:

I wrote to Father asking him to give me all the information he could relative to his father‚ grandfather‚ etc. He knows nothing farther back than his grandfather who was John instead of Charles Marion….

  1. Edgar Allen—born 10 May 1777. Married 1 Jan 1800 to Grace Taylor. That Spring moved to Eastern Tennessee where a large family was raised consisting of seven boys and four girls. There is no further record‚ except of his death‚ which took place Jun 3 1852‚ so far as is known‚ save that founded in tradition. Those however claiming Edgar as their primogenitor are found in TN‚ MS‚ AR‚ and MO.

There is no record of this marriage. Nor does this family appear in the 1800 census of Tennessee‚ or in any subsequent census records.

  1. Sarah Jane—born 29 Aug 1779. Married on 29 Jun 1803 to Dr. Lovik Pierce‚ the father of Bishop Pierce. There were six children‚ three boys and three girls. All lived and married and raised large families.

According to the North Carolina Historical and Genealogical Register, Vol. 1, No. 4 (Oct. 1900), Rev. Lovick Pierce, D.D., of Georgia was the son of Philip Pierce and Lydia Culpepper and he was the father of Bishop George F. Pierce of the Methodist Episcopal Church South. According to The Pierces and Their Posterity compiled by Clara Waldron Pierce, James Pierce McClurkin and Graham L. Pierce (printed and bound by the Parthenon Press, n.d.) p. 76, there was a Lovick Pierce, Jr. and Sr. and Lovick Pierce, Sr. was the son of Phillip and Martha (Andrews) Pierce and Lovick Pierce, Sr. was the husband of Lydia Culpepper.

  1. Sally Ann—born 20 Nov 1780‚ married Walter P. Jones‚ a rich planter of true American stock. There were eight children‚ six boys and two girls.

Sally is a nickname for Sarah‚ so the two girls had the same first name. No record of this marriage has ever been found.

When the Fairfax estate in Virginia‚ which came to him by his wife Catherine, was confiscated in the year 1780‚ Charles Marion and his brother Alfred laid claim to that portion of the estate which their father Sam Low had been manager of‚ and where all his children were born and raised.

The "him" appears to refer to Thomas, fifth Lord Fairfax. Catherine Culpeper‚ was the daughter of Thomas‚ the second Lord Culpeper. Thomas‚ fifth Lord Fairfax died in 1710 and his wife‚ Catherine‚ died in 1719. The land passed to their son‚ Thomas‚ sixth Lord Fairfax and, on his death in 1781‚ the land passed to his brother‚ Robert‚ seventh Lord Fairfax with a sixth interest to his nephew‚ Denney Martin. They owned the land in 1786 when the Virginia Assembly abolished the proprietorship. 

They were deeded by the Virginia Council ten thousand acres of land‚ the greater part lying in Culpeper Co., VA.

As noted above‚ no Culpeper/Culpepper appears in marriage‚ land‚ or probate records of Culpeper Co.‚ VA.

It was on 11 Feb 1794 that he died‚ leaving his children not only riches in land‚ but the goodly heritage of a Godly life.

No mention of Charles Marion Culpeper has ever been found in any record‚ in Virginia‚ or elsewhere.

 

Last Revised: 12 Jul 2004

 

 
 Home Up Index Search Sending Info DNA About

Culpepper Connections! The Culpepper Family History Site